Band Saw Vs Scroll Saw. Best Comparison of 2021 and Which One Should I BUY?

if you are thinking about the difference between Band saw vs scroll saw -which one should I have to buy you are in the perfect place. The right tools are essential no matter what you do, whether you’re a carpenter, decorator, woodworker, handyman, or anything in between. To be able to make the right cuts with the right machine, you need a range of saws

Choosing the right Band Saw Vs Scroll Saw tools to use for your woodworking projects is important. One question that comes up often is: Scroll Saw vs Band Saw? The answer will be different depending on what you plan to do and how much money you want to spend. Band Saw Vs Scroll Saw have their benefits depending on what you need them for!

Scroll saws and band saws are both intricate cutting tools that have a variety of applications in the woodworking industry. They both use fine blades to cut through materials with circular motions, but a few differences between them make each tool unique.

Scroll saws excel at intricate cuts as well as straight lines but are limited in width and depth of cut while band saws can handle larger pieces easier but struggle with smaller curves and detailed designs due to difficulty maintaining blade tension during those types of cuts.

if you want to gather some more information related to the Band saw and Scroll saw read the paragraph below

Best Difference between Band Saw Vs Scroll Saw

 The Best Comparison of Jointer vs planner

Scroll saw

Band Saw Vs Scroll Saw

A scroll saw is a small electric or pedal-operated saw which makes intricate curves and patterns in wood, metal, or other materials. It consists of a vertically moving blade guided by two flat metal plates with holes- one above the base plate and one below it. A foot or so above the edge is a table with a hole in it to allow the material being cut to fall through as it gets cut

The workpiece is moved manually across the cutting line drawn on the table, hence the term ‘scroll’ saw. Scroll saws have been around since at least the 1840s when they were used for cutting lace patterns into fabric. One advantage that this type of hand-held machine has over larger versions such as band saws is the smaller blades that are used.

Because of this, they can be made much more precisely, with teeth that are incredibly close together. This allows for the saw to cut very fine details into wood or other materials, which simply cannot be done by a larger band saw.

In some cases, scroll saws have been replaced by laser cutting technology as it makes cleaner cuts, and electric-powered scroll saws make consistent cuts over time whereas professional-quality human-powered ones require a bit of effort on your part to create consistent results.

In most home workshops, however, a scroll saw remains a useful tool whenever making intricate profiles or patterns out of wood or metal is required.

THROAT

A scroll saw’s throat size is something you’ll see when you shop for one(also occasionally referred to as the “scroll depth.”)This measurement is the distance between the blade and the vertical column that connects the overhead arm to the back of the saw.

 What is the importance of this? The size of the material determines how you can work with it.

Due to these machines being made differently by different manufacturers, throat sizes can vary a great deal from one brand to another. However, most throat sizes are classified in fractions of an inch, such as 1/8th or 1/4th inch throats. They all refer roughly to how high you can cut into a piece of wood before it falls free of the saw and falls to the floor.

When you do determine your throat size, keep in mind that since the depth is measured from where the blade sits, material thicknesses can drastically affect what size materials you can work with. For example, if you have a 1/8” scroll depth and want to use 100-pound cardstock for your cuts,

you may only be able to fit 12 sheets of paper side by side–not an efficient use of time or material!

I’m wondering how long can something be before it starts to overheat the motor. In other words, how long can you cut?

  Yes, this is a very subjective question. It depends on what you are cutting, the size of the blade being used, the type of wood, or whatever you cutting into or through. If you have a variable speed machine then faster speeds will use less electricity and last longer but be careful not to go too fast because that will cause chattering

(non-smooth movement) which will heat the blade quickly. If there isn’t much going on in one spot (if it’s all smooth), then yes you could probably go forever with the blade you have. If your cutting intricate designs or tight curves then you go through blades faster because it takes more power to cut those types of designs.

BLADE

Depending on the type of material you’ll be cutting it may be possible to cut through 2-inches with a regular scroll blade that hasn’t been tensioned or set up in any way. and you can cut throw 6 inches as well

You’ll also need a sharp blade. If you’re cutting curves, one very important thing is to get the fulcrum (or pivot point) of your cut right; if it’s not positioned correctly around where your material wants to bend, you’re going to break a lot of blades.

To use this saw, the blade has to be tensioned so it doesn’t buckle or wander while cutting.

One thing to try is angling your workpiece toward the back of the saw table.

This will create a small pivot point and give you much more control than without such an angle.

Exceeding the capacity of the scroll saw by applying too much pressure will result in binding or buckling, which can damage your blade and even break it.

The blade is the biggest difference between a scroll saw and a band saw.

As mentioned above, there’s an incredible variety of blades that you can use.

A regular scroll blade is very thin and flexible. It’s not as long as a band saw blade, but it does bend quite a bit.

To cut curves with less material removal, you have to angle your workpiece so gravity will pull it down toward the table as you cut. This increases the tension on the blade and your control over the material.

Benefits of Scroll saw

  • scroll saw is being able to complete intricate cuts easily and quickly. The design makes it easy to move through projects without getting bogged down by cumbersome weight or size, while its construction lets you make accurate cuts easily.
  • Scroll saw or easy to use even if you did not use any saw you can use scroll saw with ease
  • If you want to cut  dovetail joint you can cut with the scroll saw 
  • Scroll saw is used to cut the curve designs
  • Scroll saw come with the dust collector and a light in the top of the table 
  • A regular scroll blade is very thin and flexible
  • Scroll saw have table tilting feature to cut the wood in differant angles

Here is the best scroll saw for you if you want to buy

DEWALT Scroll Saw, Variable-Speed, 1.3 Amp, 20-Inch (DW788)
DEWALT Scroll Saw, Variable-Speed, 1.3 Amp, 20-Inch (DW788)

Pros

  •  Saw’s intuitive, design is convenient controls to keep your workflow smooth
  •  In scroll saw, they have the blade guard safety 
  • The blower works and has a long, bendable arm, you can position it where you want.
  • The upper arm can be raised to make it easier to insert the top part of the blade into your project for inside cuts
  • That foot pedal is very useful. When I need a break  I take my foot off the pedal and it comes to a “dead stop
  • The blades have flat ends too, which make them easy to install
  •  It was an easy and quick setup
  •  The speed and blade tension levers are functional and very easy to use.
  • It is very easy to use, especially to lift the arm and make inside cuts.
  •  The stand is very heavy to absorb vibrations from the saw
  •  The variable speeds are great for different projects and different kinds of wood

Cons

  • Little more in  the weight (56lbs)
  • Price is high

Here is the budget scroll saw for you if you want to buy

                WEN 3921 16-inch Two-Direction Variable Speed Scroll Saw
WEN 3921 16-inch Two-Direction Variable Speed Scroll Saw

Band saw

A band saw is a type of power saw. It consists of a narrow, toothed band made of high carbon steel that rotates at high speed and runs between two large wheels with crescent-shaped teeth called ‘frames’. The frames are mounted on either side of the blade so the band passes through the cut twice, once on each side.

The advantage is having enough tension in the blade to allow for good cutting action without needing roller bearings or guides. This makes it less expensive while still being accurate enough for delicate work.

Band saws come in many different sizes from miniature hobby models to industrial machines several meters wide. A smaller variant is a jeweler’s saw which is a lightweight, folding design capable of precise work such as cutting a bezel to fit a stone.

Some band saws have only one blade, but most have two blades giving better control of the cut and allowing each blade to cut a narrower range of wood/metal by having a different tooth pattern from the other blade. One could use different blades for cutting metal or plastic rather than changing them when switching from wood to metal or vice versa.

Benefits of Band Saw

  • A band saw is a type of power-saw in which a thin, toothed steel band performs the cutting action. The cutters are usually arranged in groups called “sets”.
  •  The band saw Cutters can also be chosen for their special characteristics, e.g., cutting sheet metal, rip cuts on solid wood, or cross-cutting on wood
  • A band saw is not only used for woodworking. you can use this saw to cut the timber cutting and for meat cutting
  • Band saws are used to do straight cutting where there might be curved or irregular shapes involved
  • A band saw blades are available with many different configurations of the set. Variations include the number of teeth per inch (single, double, triple)
  • Alternating top bevel or flat top; and the way that the gullets slope out from the blade center point to minimize binding

Here is the best band saw if you want to buy

 JET JWBS-14SFX 14" Steel-Frame Bandsaw (714400K)

JET JWBS-14SFX 14″ Steel-Frame Bandsaw (714400K)

Pros

  •  Cast Iron wheels have more momentum  less slowing down on cuts
  • Very well made, easy to assemble, works very well.
  • The fence is very well made 
  • The saw has a powerful 1.75hp motor
  • 13″ Re-saw capacity
  • Timberwolf blades in 116″ sizes of various widths
  •  Quick-release tensioner lever.
  • Super quiet

Cons

  •  The saw is huge and extremely heavy
  • Tensioner assembly is terrible

Here is the budget saw for you if you want to buy

WEN 3962T 3.5-Amp 10-Inch Two-Speed Band Saw with Stand and Worklight

WEN 3962T 3.5-Amp 10-Inch Two-Speed Band Saw with Stand and Worklight

Comparison of Band Saw Vs Scroll Saw

Features:Scroll Saw:Band Saw
Blade Speed:1200-1900 SPM2600 ft/m
Blade Length: 5-inches60-inches
PortabilityPortableDifficult to move
Weight:  56 pounds250 pounds
Dust Collectorhave dust collectorhave dust collector
Baldepin ended bladeinbuilt belt a lop type blade
Safetysafe to use safe to use
Crosscutsleddo not crosscut sledcan crosscut sled
Noiseless noisemore noise
Locking Keydo not have a lock keyhave the lock key
Materialcan cut 2 inches thickercan cut 12 inches thicker

CONCLUSION

We hope that we have helped you learn a little more about the differences between band saws and scroll saws.

If you’re looking for a saw to do precision woodworking, scroll saws can be the best option. They are better at making detailed cuts and they work well with smaller projects. However, if you need to cut larger pieces of lumber or metal then band saws may be more appropriate as they have greater cutting capacity than their counterpart.

 Overall, we recommend both types of tools depending on your needs because each has its own strengths and weaknesses that could come in handy when it comes time to make those tough decisions about which one is right for your next project.

please feel free to reach out to us with any questions or concerns!

Leave a Comment